top of page

AMG v. FTC: Prelude to the CARS Rule

Transition from a courtroom scene to a car dealership setting, illustrating the shift from legal proceedings to automotive compliance with visual elements emphasizing transparency, fairness, and ethical sales practices.

The landmark case of AMG Capital Management vs. FTC has reshaped the regulatory landscape and set the stage for the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) CARS Rule. This blog post delves into the AMG v. FTC case and explores its implications for the automotive industry, particularly the introduction and enforcement of the CARS Rule.

Understanding the AMG v. FTC Case

AMG Capital Management, a financial institution, was fined $1.27 billion for alleged unethical practices. Challenging the FTC's authority to impose such fines, AMG took the case to the Supreme Court. The unanimous 9-0 verdict in favor of AMG clarified that the FTC lacked the legal power to directly impose financial penalties, necessitating a new approach to enforce regulations and combat deceptive practices.

A Supreme Court Decision that Reshaped the FTC's Role

The Supreme Court's decision in AMG v. FTC highlighted a significant gap in the FTC's enforcement capabilities. Without the authority to impose financial penalties, the FTC needed a specific rule to address deceptive practices in industries like automotive sales. This led to the creation of the "Combating Auto Retail Scams" (CARS) Rule.

Enter the CARS Rule: A New Era of Regulation

The CARS Rule was developed to fill the enforcement gap revealed by the AMG v. FTC case. It empowers the FTC to take action against dealerships that engage in deceptive advertising, mislead consumers about financing options, or sell add-ons that provide no real value. The regulation aims to ensure transparency and fairness in the car-buying process, marking a significant shift toward stricter regulations for car dealerships.

Why This Matters for the Automotive Industry

While enforcement of the CARS Rule is currently not in effect pending judicial review, the introduction of the Rule signifies a new era of compliance for the automotive industry. Dealerships must now prioritize ethical sales practices and transparent communication with customers. If the rule survives, the FTC will be equipped with more robust enforcement mechanisms.

Watch the Full Keynote Video for Deeper Insights

Gain a deeper understanding of the CARS Rule, its current state, and its potential future by watching the full keynote video featuring industry expert James S. Ganther, Esq. This comprehensive analysis provides valuable insights to help you stay informed and compliant in this evolving regulatory landscape.

Stay Updated on Automotive Compliance:

Subscribe to our blog for ongoing discussions on the CARS Rule, automotive compliance updates, and industry best practices. Follow us on LinkedIn to join the conversation and stay ahead of the curve. Let's navigate the world of automotive commerce together!

More About the CARS Rule:


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page